Chat with us, powered by LiveChat

Ban on political robocalls violates First Amendment, 9th Circuit rules

Ban on political robocalls violates First Amendment, 9th Circuit rules

First Amendment


Image from

A Montana law that bans political robocalls is a content-based restriction that violates the First Amendment, a federal appeals court has ruled.

The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals at San Francisco ruled for Victory Processing, the political consulting company challenging the law. The Associated Press and Courthouse News Service have coverage, while How Appealing links to the opinion, which was filed Tuesday.

The Montana law had barred automated calls in five categories, including calls promoting or related to a political campaign. The other banned categories were calls that offered goods or services, calls that conveyed information on goods or services in soliciting purchases, calls that solicited information, and calls that gathered data or statistics. Violations carry a fine of up to $2,500.

Robocalls are permitted in the state, however, if a live operator gets permission to play the recorded message from the called party.

The 9th Circuit noted a 2015 decision by the 4th Circuit at Richmond, Virginia, that struck down a ban on all consumer and political robocalls in South Carolina. The 4th Circuit said the ban was not narrowly tailored to protect the state’s interest in protecting privacy.

The 9th Circuit said the same reasoning applied to the Montana ban.

“Notably, according to the Montana state legislature, the privacy threat posed by robocalls relates to the methods or effects of robocalls—the fact that they tie up phone lines and fill answering machines—rather than their content,” the 9th Circuit said in an opinion by Judge Richard A. Paez. “Accordingly, regulating robocalls based on their content does not address Montana’s expressed concerns.”

READ  Morning Docket: 04.20.17

The case is Victory Processing v. Fox.

Be Sociable, Share!

Author: Edward Lott

Edward Lott, Ph.D., M.B.A. is President and Managing Partner of Allentown-based ForLawFirmsOnly Marketing, Inc., a local search and digital marketing agency that offers clients lead generation, local seo and Google Maps Domination.Ed has been a digital entrepreneur since 1994, having discovered very early the opportunities the Internet offered. After having spent over two decades helping attorneys grow their practice, Ed joined the staff of ForLawFirmsOnly Marketing as President and Managing Partner, where he is expanding the agency’s cutting-edge services to the legal market.A true marketing futurist, Ed's vast experience working directly with attorneys has given him a unique perspective on law firm marketing not found in many other digital marketing agencies. Ed has reshaped the offerings of ForLawFirmsOnly to focus on growing law firms through a holistic approach to digital marketing evident in the reformulated lead generation processes now in place.Want to learn more about ForLawFirmsOnly Marketing, their lead generation programs, or just talk to Ed about his visions for helping law firms grow? Call him at 855-943-8736.

ForLawFirmsOnly Marketing, Inc. © 1994-2019 All Rights Reserved
Scroll Up